Newton's
Bulletin
Issue n. 5, June 2015 - Assessment of GOCE Geopotential Models [pp. 105-126]
Evaluation of EGM 2008 and EIGEN-6C3stat by means of data from GNSS/leveling
| Download
file |
Abstract
The Gravity field and steady-state Ocean Circulation Explorer (GOCE) dedicated
satellite gravity field mission was launched by the European Space Agency (ESA) on March
17, 2009. Since then, several Global Geopotential Models (GGMs) have been released based
on data collected by GOCE.
This paper evaluates different GOCE-only and GOCE/GRACE GGMs using 567 available
GPS/Levelling points and terrestrial free-air gravity anomalies in Argentina.
EGM2008 and EIGEN-51C models are also included in the evaluation procedure, even
though they are not based on GOCE data. The idea of using these models is to identify
any improvements of the new GOCE-only or GOCE/GRACE GGMs in Argentina. The truncation
of the Stokes coefficients at a certain spherical harmonic degree n1 produces an
omission error. In order to reduce this omission error, synthetic GGMs are evaluated
by adding signal from EGM2008 and topographic effects through a Residual Terrain Model
(RTM) to the satellite GGMs models. The evaluation is performed with an incremental
step of one in harmonic degree, so that the most detailed possible evaluation of the
GOCE-only and GOCE/GRACE GGMs will be performed. The results show that EGM2008 is
better than all GGMs, used for evaluation in this study, in terms of the standard
deviation of the geoid heights are concerned. This superiority is marginal and
statistically insignificant, being at the 3-2 mm level. GOCE/GRACE GGMs are
significantly better than EGM2008 in terms of the range of the differences with the
GPS/Levelling data, since they reduce the 1.964 m of the EGM2008 range by as much
as 0.21 m for DIR_R5.
Contrary to the results for the validation with the GPS/Levelling data, all the GOCE and GOCE/GRACE GGMs are better at the 0.1 mGal level for the gravity anomaly differences.



